A God In Ruins – A review

Let me start out by saying that Kate Atkinson is one of my writing heroes. I love the way that she twists her plots and just when you think you’ve worked it all out, there’s another twist, sometimes on the last page. Her Jackson Brodie novels are my favourites (unsurprisingly given the crime genre) but ‘Life After Life’ runs an extremely close second. Wait a minute, you say, this review is for ‘A God In Ruins’. Yes, indeed it is but you can’t review the latter without looking at the former first. In fact, I would say that in order to understand ‘A God In Ruins’, you have to read ‘Life After Life’ first.

‘Life After Life’ is, as the title suggests, the recurring lives of Ursula Todd. Ursula appears to be stuck in a cyclical journey of birth, death and rebirth. But unlike reincarnation, it is her own life that she continually returns to, apparently learning from her previous mistakes. She doesn’t actually remember each life but there’s a whisper or sixth sense that tells her to take or not take a certain path. It is the most brilliant book and it was a struggle to put it down. I marvelled too at the plotting of the story (how did she do it?!) and it’s one of those novels that I think will stay with me for the rest of my life.

Atkinson considers ‘A God in Ruins’ as a companion book, more than a mere sequel to ‘Life After Life’. In the author notes she explains that she wanted to write a book about World War Two, focusing on the areas that fascinated her the most – the Blitz and the bombing campaign of Germany. She explores the Blitz through Ursula’s eyes but it was apparent to her that there was too much material for just one book. So she explores the bombing campaign through Ursula’s younger brother, Teddy, a pilot in Bomber Command.

Naturally though, Kate Atkinson doesn’t stick with a conventional timeline and Teddy’s life is explored in different time periods with episodes from before the war, during and after, interweaving together. There are also sections that are seen from others’ viewpoints – Nancy, his wife; Viola, his daughter; Sunny, his grandson and Bertie, his granddaughter.

I have to confess that I didn’t find A God In Ruins as compelling as Life After Life. I preferred having Teddy as the narrator although the chapter from Sunny’s viewpoint had me in tears and I would have liked to know more about him. Sadly, I can’t say the same about his mother, Viola, who is truly vile. But there is a lovely section where I suspect Atkinson is doing a little self-mocking:

‘She [Viola] wished she had asked him about his war when he was still compos mentis. She might have been able to use his memories as the basis of a novel. One that everyone would respect. People always took war novels seriously.’

And that’s what I love about Kate Atkinson. She never takes herself too seriously. She’s not pretentious. There is always humour shot through her books. And of course, just when I thought that this would be a four star book for me, she pulled it out of the bag, right at the very end, with, in her own words, ‘a bit of trickery.’

So, in conclusion, ‘A God In Ruins’ gets five stars from me. I have no idea what Kate Atkinson is working on next but I do hope it’s another Jackson Brodie novel. Go on Kate, just for me.

2 thoughts on “A God In Ruins – A review

  1. I’m with you on your opinion of Kate Atkinson – she is an utter genius. I actually haven’t read A God In Ruins as – and I know this is a bit pathetic – we really don’t know when we’ll get the next one! I’ve loved all her novels, even the collection of short stories (and I’m not hugely keen on them!) She’s an “auto-buy” author, isn’t she?


    1. I can tell you that there is a new book coming! I saw her at Wimbledon Bookfest at the weekend & she read from her manuscript. It’s called Transcription and is set in two time periods – 1940 & 1950. The protagonist, Juliet, is first a transcriber for MI5 in the war and then joins the BBC after the war. She’s hoping it will come out next year and the passage she read was brilliant!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s